Bookmark this how to make ice cream sandwiches tutorial to make your own out of this world ice cream desserts.
Looking for more neat summer ideas? Check out these: fun outdoor swings to transform your tired backyard swing set, diy refreshing homemade popsicle for kids and adults alike, summer inspired fruit salad recipes
Are you interested in learning how to make ice cream sandwiches?
Here is a detailed tutorial for making the best homemade ice cream sandwiches with a list of quick and easy ice cream sandwich treats you can easily make yourself.
How To Make Ice Cream Sandwiches
Ice cream sandwiches are delightful, satisfying treats that are perfect for a hot summer day. They’re a fan favorite among kids and adults alike and make for the best after dinner or late afternoon treat. And, with this quick and easy how to make ice cream sandwiches tutorial you’ll ditch store bought for homemade!
Who wouldn’t want to bite into a block of chilly ice cream sandwiched between two delicious, chewy cookies?
You and your family might actually start looking forward to the hot summer months when you know how to make ice cream sandwiches yourself.
We love quick and easy recipes at This Tiny Blue House. So, we want to help you master the art of how to make ice cream sandwiches for times when the craving strikes with this step by step tutorial about how to make ice cream sandwiches from scratch.
The process is relatively easy to master, and homemade ice cream sandwiches are so much tastier than the cheap store bought versions you find in the freezer sections of grocery stores.
Plus, with this easy how to make ice cream sandwiches tutorial you can make creative and delicious ice cream sandwich desserts using a variety of cookies, ice cream flavors and toppings. You control the flavors so the possibilities are truly endless which is what we love most about this how to make ice cream sandwiches tutorial and recipe list.
What will you find in this post? First, we’ve provided a detailed step by step guide about how to make ice cream sandwiches from absolute scratch. From there, we found and curated 25 of the absolute best and most over the top (aka super decadent) ice cream sandwiches that you can make to master your new ice cream sandwich making skills.
In a rush? Click here to save this how to make ice cream sandwiches tutorial and recipes to Pinterest.
Why Make Your Own Ice Cream Sandwiches?
You may ask, what’s the point of making your own ice cream sandwiches when you can walk into pretty much any major grocery store and buy a box of them?
There are lots of reasons why homemade ice cream sandwiches are better than store bought ones. The main reason we love homemade ice cream sandwiches is because when you make your own, you have the power to customize your ice cream sandwiches any way you want.
When you buy a box of ice cream sandwiches from the grocery store, you’re typically limited to the three standard options – vanilla, strawberry, and chocolate. Making your ice cream treats gives you the opportunity to exercise your creativity in the kitchen and make a treat that’s truly your own. Take some inspiration from our list of DIY ice cream sandwich recipes below!
When you make your own ice cream sandwiches from scratch, you also have more control over the ingredients. Like most boxed store bought items, many varieties of premade ice cream sandwiches are full of ingredients that are impossible to pronounce.
Also, making ice cream sandwiches is fun. It’s a great activity for the whole family to do together, and it will be easy to convince your kids to join in because of the delicious reward they’ll get at the end!
How to Make Ice Cream Sandwiches
Making ice cream sandwiches is a much simpler process than you might think. Here are the general steps to make a delicious ice cream sandwich:
- Make the cookie batter. Combine all of the ingredients for the cookies. Traditionally, the cookies on the outside of an ice cream sandwich are thin and chocolate flavored. Follow your specific recipe, but note that most recipes call for flour, cocoa, chocolate chips, butter, sugar, and eggs.
- Bake the cookies. Spread the cookie batter onto two sheet pans. These cookies bake in two full sheets that you can cut into pieces after they are set and assembled.
- Beat the ice cream. Use an electric mixer with a paddle attachment or an ice cream maker to make whatever flavor ice cream you want. Traditionally, ice cream sandwiches call for vanilla ice cream, but make it your own! Anything works when it comes to making ice cream sandwiches so feel free to experiment with different flavors.
- Spread the ice cream on the cookies. Before cutting up the sandwiches, spread the ice cream onto the large, cooled cookie. Flip the other cookie over onto the ice cream layer and press down gently.
- Freeze for a few hours. The ice cream sandwiches need to freeze and become more solid before you can cut them. This makes portioning out your sandwiches a lot easier.
- Cut into rectangles or shapes. Finally, the time is here! Cut your large ice cream sandwich into individual sized ice cream sandwiches. Serve immediately or wrap each sandwich with plastic wrap and return them to the freezer.
As you can tell, the process of making ice cream sandwiches isn’t too complicated!
Now that you know how to make ice cream sandwiches from scratch, explore some of the different ways you can add some variety to the traditional recipe.
Here are 25 of our favorite DIY ice cream sandwich recipes for you to try out!
In a rush? Click here to save this how to make ice cream sandwiches tutorial and recipes to Pinterest.
Homemade Ice Cream Sandwich Recipes
1. Chocolate Cookie Ice Cream Sandwiches: If you love a good traditional ice cream sandwich this is it. Creamy chocolate chip ice cream is sandwiched between soft chocolate cookies to create this delicious frozen treat. (Visit The Baker Mama for the complete recipe)
2. Oreo Brownie Ice Cream Sandwiches: If you’re an Oreo lover you’re gonna want to try this Oreo Brownie ice cream sandwich. Homemade no churn Oreo ice cream is loaded between two brownie chocolate cookies. (Visit Buuk Farms Bakery for the complete recipe)
3. Funfetti Cookie Ice Cream Sandwiches: Kids love sprinkles and these Funfetti ice cream sandwiches do not disappoint. Creamy vanilla bean ice cream is wedged between soft and chewy Funetti cookies to create the ultimate dessert. (Visit Lulus for the complete recipe)
4. Cookie Dough Ice Cream Sandwiches: If you love cookie dough then these homemade ice cream sandwiches are a must try. This quick and easy ice cream sandwich recipe is for folks who seriously love cookie dough. (Visit Marissa’s Kitchen for the complete recipe)
5. Coffee Brownie Ice Cream Sandwiches: Coffees and brownies work so well together. Creamy cold brew coffee ice cream is sandwiched between two ultra rich fudge brownie cookies. (Visit Handle The Heat for the complete recipe)
Save these homemade ice cream sandwich recipes for later. Click here to save this how to make ice cream sandwiches tutorial and recipes to Pinterest. This way, if you’re ever stuck asking yourself how to make ice cream sandwiches you can easily come back to this post.
6. Waffle Ice Cream Sandwiches: Swap out the cookies for waffles in this quick and easy waffle ice cream sandwich recipe. We recommend a Belgian waffle iron to make huge fluffy sandwich waffles. (Visit The Sweet Escape for the complete recipe)
7. Waffle Ice Cream Cereal Sandwiches: If you don’t have time to make homemade waffles, frozen waffles can work too! These waffle ice cream cereal sandwiches combine a variety of flavors to create a cool ice cream summer treat. (Visit Let’s Eat Cake for the complete recipe)
8. Fruity Pebbles Ice Cream Sandwiches: Love fruity pebbles? Roll your ice cream sandwich in the sweet crunchy cereal! (Visit Delish for the complete recipe)
9. S’mores Ice Cream Sandwiches: This creative ice cream sandwich blends all the delicious S’more flavors together to create a luscious S’more ice cream sandwich loaded with toasted marshmallow ice cream. (Visit A Latte Food for the complete recipe)
10. Hot Fudge Ice Cream Sandwiches: This homemade ice cream sandwich combines cookies, ice cream and hot fudge to create an over the top ice cream sandwich that kids and adults are gonna love. (Visit Half Baked Harvest for the complete recipe)
Save these homemade ice cream sandwich recipes for later. Click here to save this how to make ice cream sandwiches tutorial and recipes to Pinterest. This way, if you’re ever stuck asking yourself how to make ice cream sandwiches you can easily come back to this post.
11. M&M Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches: Love M&Ms? Then, you’re going to go crazy for this ice cream treat that sandwiches homemade vanilla ice cream between two soft and chewy M&M cookies. (Visit Sally’s Baking Addiction for the complete recipe)
12. Galaxy Ice Cream Sandwiches: Looking for a homemade ice cream sandwich that is out of this world? Then, you gotta try your hand at making these funky galaxy ice cream sandwiches. (Visit A Bajillion Recipes for the complete recipe)
13. Nutter Butter Ice Cream Sandwiches: If you’re looking for a low carb treat then this is it. Creamy sugar free peanut butter ice cream is sandwiched between two low carb peanut butter cookies to create this guilt free treat. (Visit All Day I Dream About Food for the complete recipe)
14. Mini Ice Cream Sandwich Pops: Get creative by putting your ice cream sandwiches on sticks! Roll them in sprinkles to make them an extra colorful treat kids will love. (Visit The Girl Inspired for the complete recipe)
15. Cake Batter Cookie Ice Cream Sandwiches: Sandwich your favorite creamy ice cream between two soft and chewy cake batter cookies to create this heavenly homemade ice cream sandwich.(Visit Sally’s Baking Addiction for the complete recipe)
In a rush? Click here to save this how to make ice cream sandwiches tutorial and recipes to Pinterest.
16. Churro Ice Cream Sandwiches: Churros and ice cream are the BEST combination. Sandwich rich vanilla bean ice cream between two cinnamon sugar Churro’s to create a divine ice cream treat the whole family will love. (Visit Chelsea’s Messy Apron for the complete recipe)
17. Strawberry Shortcake Ice Cream Sandwiches: If you love traditional strawberry shortcake then you’ve gotta try this quick and easy twist on a traditional ice cream sandwich. Layer creamy ice cream and strawberries between slices of pound cake to create this quick and easy dessert. (Visit Pint Sized Baker for the complete recipe)
18. Fruity Pebbles Ice Cream Sandwiches: Mix and match your favorite ice cream flavors with fruity pebbles to create these really simple fruity pebbles ice cream sandwiches. (Visit Cookies and Cups for the complete recipe)
19. Oreo Ice Cream Sandwich Madness: Do you remember the TGI Friday’s Oreo Madness cookie dessert? If you do then you’re gonna want to make this copy cat version that tastes just as good! (Visit It’s Always Autumn for the complete recipe)
20. Tahini Chocolate Ice Cream Sandwiches: Rich and creamy chocolate ice cream is loaded between two yummy tahini cookies to create this decadent summer treat. (Visit The Feed Feed for the complete recipe)
In a rush? Click here to save this how to make ice cream sandwiches tutorial and recipes to Pinterest.
21. Chocolate Dipped Ice Cream Sandwiches: Create over the top ice cream sandwiches by dipping your individual sandwiches in chocolate and loading them with sprinkles, nuts and any other toppings you love. (Visit Mr Food for the complete recipe)
22. Oatmeal Rum Raisin Ice Cream Sandwiches: If you’re a fan of oatmeal and rum raisin then these ice cream treats are a must try. Creamy rum raisin ice cream is sandwiched between two chewy homemade oatmeal cookies. (Visit The Candid Appetite for the complete recipe)
23. Peanut Butter Fudge Ice Cream Sandwiches: If you love peanut butter as much as we do then you have to try these peanut butter fudge treats. Creamy ice-cream loaded with chunks of peanut butter fudge is sandwiched between rich chocolate cookies to create an absolute delicious homemade ice cream sandwich. (Visit The Sugar Hit for the complete recipe)
24. Vegan Ice Cream Sandwiches: These quick and easy vegan ice cream sandwiches are the perfect ice cold treat on a HOT summer day. A large scoop of creamy non dairy ice cream made from coconut milk is wedged between vegan chocolate chip cookies to create this healthy treat.(Visit Life Made Sweeter for the complete recipe)
25. Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwiches: Love everything about the mint and chocolate flavor combination? Then, you gotta try making these quick and easy mint chocolate chip ice cream sandwiches this supper.(Visit The Blu Manor Blog for the complete recipe)
Save these homemade ice cream sandwich recipes for later. Click here to save this how to make ice cream sandwiches tutorial and recipes to Pinterest. This way, if you’re ever stuck asking yourself how to make ice cream sandwiches you can easily come back to this post.
26. Rice Krispies Ice Cream Sandwiches: Do you love Rice Krispies treats? Then, you gotta try sandwiching creamy ice cream between rice Krispies squares (Visit La Jolla Mom for the complete recipe)
27. Blueberry Pie Ice Cream Sandwiches: This clever twist on a traditional ice cream sandwich loads creamy ice cream between two blueberry hand pies. Genius right?(Visit The Kitchen McCabe for the complete recipe)
28. Donut Ice Cream Sandwiches: Donut ice cream sandwiches? Why not! This epic ice cream sandwich loads no churn Toasted Mocha Marshmallow-flavored ice cream into soft bakery donuts to create the most epic summer treat. (Visit Sugar Spun Run for the complete recipe)
29. Lucky Charms Ice Cream Sandwiches: Lucky charms pair beautifully with ice cream! Soft cookies loaded with lucky charms provide the perfect vessel for cool creamy ice cream. (Visit Simply Wisked for the complete recipe)
30. Skinny Macaroon Ice Cream Sandwiches: At less than 100 calories per sandwich these skinny macaroon ice cream sandwiches are bite sized decadence at its finest. Creamy vanilla ice cream is sandwiched between macaroons that have been separated like an Oreo. (Visit Sugar and Cloth for the complete recipe)
Do you plan on trying this how to make ice cream sandwiches tutorial soon? Click here to save these delicious ice cream sandwich recipes to Pinterest so you can quickly find this post.