Looking for a fun Thanksgiving math activity for preschool and kindergarten? This adorable pumpkin pie number matching game is a hands-on way for kids to practice counting, number recognition, and one-to-one correspondence while matching whole pumpkin pies with the correct number of slices!
Thanksgiving Pumpkin Pie Number Matching Game
There’s just something about pumpkin pie that makes Thanksgiving extra special! 🥧
And this year, we’re bringing a little pumpkin pie fun into our preschool and kindergarten math centers with a brand-new Thanksgiving pumpkin pie number matching game!
This free printable activity includes 10 whole pumpkin pie cards numbered 1–10 and 10 matching cards featuring the corresponding number of pumpkin pie slices.
Children count the slices, identify the number on the whole pie, and find the matching pair.
It’s simple, colorful, and a fun way to sneak a little early math practice into your Thanksgiving celebrations.
I especially love activities like this because they feel more like a game than traditional math practice. Little learners get to count, match, and play while strengthening important early numeracy skills.
Whether you’re planning November classroom centers, looking for Thanksgiving crafts and activities, or simply need a screen-free activity to keep little hands busy, this printable is a fun choice!
RELATED: If your kids love hands-on learning games, be sure to check out our Thanksgiving alphabet matching game for a festive way to practice uppercase and lowercase letters.
Why You’ll Love This Thanksgiving Number Matching Game
This pumpkin pie counting game is one of those activities that’s easy to prepare and can be used again and again.
Here’s why I think you’ll love it:
- 🥧 Free printable: Download, print, and prepare the cards for an easy Thanksgiving math activity. Get the pdf at the very bottom of this blog post.
- 🔢 Numbers 1–10: Perfect for preschoolers and kindergarteners learning to recognize numbers and count objects.
- ✂️ Fine motor practice: Cutting, picking up, and arranging the cards helps strengthen little hand muscles.
- 🧡 Hands-on learning: Children actively count pumpkin pie slices rather than simply identifying numbers on a worksheet.
- 🏫 Classroom friendly: Great for November morning tubs, math centers, small groups, and independent practice.
- ♻️ Reusable: Laminate the cards so you can enjoy this Thanksgiving counting game year after year.
And because the game uses adorable pumpkin pie illustrations, it’s also a fun activity to pair with your favorite Thanksgiving books and pumpkin-themed crafts!
What’s Included in the Free Pumpkin Pie Number Matching Printable?
Our free Thanksgiving pumpkin pie number matching game includes 20 printable matching cards covering numbers 1–10.
Each matching pair includes:
- One whole pumpkin pie card: Features a large numeral from 1–10.
- One pumpkin pie slice card: Features the corresponding number of individual pumpkin pie slices for children to count.
For example, children match the whole pumpkin pie labeled 4 with the card showing four slices of pie.
The printable includes 10 matching pairs arranged across four activity pages, plus a cover and information page.
The cards feature colorful pumpkin pie illustrations with whipped cream, easy-to-read numerals, and dotted borders for cutting.
Once the cards are prepared, you’re ready to play!
Supplies You’ll Need
One of my favorite things about printable learning games is that they don’t require a long list of supplies.
Here’s what you’ll need to prepare your pumpkin pie matching game:
- Our free Thanksgiving Pumpkin Pie Number Matching Game printable. You can snag a copy of the file at the bottom of this blog post.
- White cardstock – I recommend printing on cardstock so the cards are sturdier and easier for little hands to manage.
- Laminator or self-laminating sheets – Optional, but highly recommended if you’re planning to use the game in a classroom.
- Kid-friendly scissors – For cutting out the matching cards.
- Storage pouches – Perfect for keeping all 20 cards together.
My classroom tip: I love laminating printable games before cutting them apart. It makes the cards more durable, especially when they’re going to be used in busy preschool and kindergarten learning centers.
You can also store the finished cards in a small photo storage box or reusable zipper pouch so they’re easy to grab throughout November.
How to Prepare Your Pumpkin Pie Number Matching Game
Getting this Thanksgiving math activity ready is quick and easy!
Step 1: Download the Free Printable
Start by downloading our free Thanksgiving Pumpkin Pie Number Matching Game using the download box at the bottom of this post.
The printable includes all 10 matching pairs, covering numbers 1–10.
Step 2: Print the Matching Cards
Print the activity pages on good quality white cardstock.
I recommend printing at actual size so the cards maintain their intended proportions.
The bright orange pumpkin pies and matching slices look especially cute when printed in color!
Step 3: Laminate for Durability
If you’re planning to reuse the game, laminate the printed sheets before cutting out the individual cards.
This is especially helpful for classroom math centers, morning tubs, and small-group activities where the cards will be handled frequently.
Step 4: Cut Out the Cards
Carefully cut along the dotted borders to separate the 20 individual cards.
You’ll end up with 10 whole pumpkin pie number cards and 10 matching pumpkin pie slice cards.
Step 5: Mix, Match, and Play!
Place the whole pumpkin pie cards on one side of the table and the pumpkin pie slice cards on the other.
Invite children to choose a number card, count the corresponding number of slices, and find the matching pair.
Continue until all 10 pumpkin pies have been matched correctly.
And that’s it!
Your Thanksgiving pumpkin pie number matching game is ready for some hands-on counting fun!
How to Play the Thanksgiving Pumpkin Pie Number Matching Game
There are several ways to use these printable cards depending on your child’s age and skill level.
1. Classic Number Matching
Spread the whole pumpkin pie cards across a table or work mat.
Place the pumpkin pie slice cards in a separate pile.
Have children choose a whole pie, identify the number, and find the card showing the correct number of slices.
For example, a whole pumpkin pie labeled 6 matches the card featuring six individual slices.
This is a great activity for practicing number recognition and one-to-one correspondence.
2. Thanksgiving Math Center
Turn the printable into an independent Thanksgiving math center!
Place the laminated cards inside a small storage container and add them to your November math tubs.
Children can work independently or with a partner to count the slices and match each set to the correct numeral.
For younger preschoolers, start with numbers 1–5 and gradually introduce numbers 6–10 as their counting skills improve.
3. Pumpkin Pie Memory Game
For a fun twist, turn the cards into a Thanksgiving memory matching game.
Place the cards face down on a table and have children take turns flipping over two cards.
If they reveal a whole pumpkin pie and a slice card with the corresponding quantity, they keep the pair.
If the cards don’t match, they turn them face down and try again.
Continue playing until all the matching pairs have been found.
Tip: Start with just three or four pairs for younger children to make the game more manageable.
4. Number Order Challenge
Once children have matched all 10 pairs, encourage them to arrange the whole pumpkin pies in numerical order from 1–10.
Then, invite them to place the corresponding slice cards beneath each numeral.
For an extra challenge, remove one number card and ask children to identify which number is missing.
5. Count and Clap
This is a fun way to incorporate a little movement into your Thanksgiving math practice.
Have children select a pumpkin pie number card, identify the numeral, and clap that many times.
Then, they find the matching slice card to check their counting.
You can also have children stomp, jump, or tap the table instead of clapping.
What Skills Does This Thanksgiving Math Game Teach?
Although this printable looks like a simple matching game, it helps children develop several important early math skills.
Number recognition: Children practice identifying numerals from 1–10.
One-to-one correspondence: Counting each pumpkin pie slice helps children understand that each object represents one number in the counting sequence.
Counting and cardinality: Children learn that the final number they say when counting tells them how many objects are in a group.
Visual discrimination: Children compare groups of pumpkin pie slices and recognize differences in quantity.
Fine motor skills: Picking up, sorting, and arranging the cards helps strengthen hand-eye coordination and fine motor control.
Concentration and problem-solving: Matching the correct number of objects to a numeral encourages children to think carefully and check their work.
This makes the game especially useful for preschool, pre-K, kindergarten, and early elementary students who are still building confidence with numbers.
Download Instructions
Ready to download a copy of our pumpkin pie number matching game?
Getting your hands on our pumpkin pie number matching game is easy. Fill out the form at the bottom of this post and click the “Send Me the Printable” button.
After signing up, check your email to confirm your subscription. You will then be redirected to the printable PDF containing the template.
Already subscribed? No problem! Enter your information in the form again and you’ll be taken directly to the download.
Tip: Be sure to check your spam or promotions folder if you don’t see the email right away.
Still having trouble downloading our pumpkin pie number matching game? Check out this step-by-step download guide with images!
Please note: This printable is for personal and classroom use only. Redistribution, resale, or uploading the files to other websites or shared platforms is not permitted.
More Pumpkin Pie Crafts and Activities for Kids
If your little learners enjoyed this pumpkin pie counting game, why not turn it into a whole Thanksgiving pumpkin pie theme?
We have several adorable pumpkin pie crafts that pair perfectly with this printable!
Fingerprint Pumpkin Pie Craft
Our fingerprint pumpkin pie craft is a fun Thanksgiving process art activity that lets children create their own adorable pumpkin pie using paint and their fingertips!
This is a wonderful activity for strengthening fine motor skills while exploring colors and textures.
Pair it with the number matching game for a fun combination of Thanksgiving art and early math practice.
Torn Paper Pumpkin Pie Craft
Little learners will love creating their own slice of pumpkin pie with our torn paper pumpkin pie craft.
Children tear orange construction paper into small pieces and glue them onto a printable pie slice template before adding the crust and a fluffy cotton ball for whipped cream.
It’s a fantastic fine motor activity to pair with counting and number recognition practice.
Paper Plate Pumpkin Pie Craft
Our paper plate pumpkin pie craft is another adorable Thanksgiving art project for preschool and kindergarten.
Using a simple paper plate and basic craft supplies, children create a festive pumpkin pie that’s perfect for November classroom displays.
Pumpkin Pie Name Craft
Combine early literacy with Thanksgiving fun using our pumpkin pie name craft.
This adorable activity helps children practice identifying and sequencing the letters in their names while creating a Thanksgiving-themed craft.
Pair it with our pumpkin pie number matching game for a fun day of hands-on literacy and math activities!
More Thanksgiving Math and Literacy Activities
Looking for even more hands-on Thanksgiving learning activities?
These are some of my favorite screen-free printables and games for preschool and kindergarten.
Thanksgiving Alphabet Matching Game
Our Thanksgiving alphabet matching game is the perfect companion to this pumpkin pie number matching activity!
Children practice matching uppercase and lowercase letters while developing early literacy skills.
I love setting up both activities as separate Thanksgiving learning centers so children can rotate between math and literacy practice.
Turkey Color by Number
For more number recognition practice, try our turkey color by number printable.
Children identify numbers and use the corresponding colors to complete an adorable Thanksgiving turkey picture.
This is a great follow-up activity after playing the pumpkin pie number matching game.
Turkey Name Craft
Our turkey name craft is a fun way to practice name recognition and letter sequencing during November.
It’s an adorable addition to Thanksgiving literacy centers and makes a sweet classroom display.
Thanksgiving Thankful Turkey Printable
Encourage gratitude and self-expression with our Thanksgiving thankful turkey printable.
Children write or draw things they’re thankful for while creating a meaningful Thanksgiving activity to share with family and friends.
Thanksgiving Coloring Pages
Need an easy activity for early finishers or quiet classroom time?
Our free Thanksgiving coloring pages are perfect for preschool, kindergarten, and elementary-aged children.
Printable Thanksgiving Placemats
Our printable Thanksgiving placemats for kids are another fun way to keep little hands busy.
They’re perfect for classroom Thanksgiving celebrations, Friendsgiving parties, and the kids’ table on Thanksgiving Day.
Thanksgiving Crafts to Pair With This Number Matching Game
Want to extend the fun beyond math practice?
We have plenty of easy Thanksgiving crafts that would make adorable additions to a pumpkin pie-themed activity day!
Here are a few favorites:
- 🦃 Fork Painted Turkey Craft – Create colorful turkey feathers using a plastic fork and tempera paint.
- 🎨 Paint Splat Turkey Craft – A fun Thanksgiving process art project using colorful paint splats.
- ✂️ Torn Paper Turkey Craft – Strengthen little hand muscles by tearing and gluing colorful paper feathers.
- 🍂 Fall Leaf Turkey Craft – Turn colorful autumn leaves into adorable turkey feathers.
- 🧡 Toilet Paper Roll Stamped Turkey Craft – Use a recycled cardboard tube to stamp colorful feathers.
- 🦃 Turkey Handprint Craft – Make a sweet Thanksgiving handprint keepsake.
- 🎨 Paper Plate Turkey Craft – An easy Thanksgiving art project using simple craft supplies.
- 🍁 Easy Paper Bag Turkey Craft – Turn an ordinary paper bag into a cute turkey craft.
For even more ideas, don’t miss our complete collection of 15+ turkey crafts and activities for kids.
Thanksgiving Books to Pair With This Pumpkin Pie Number Matching Game
I love pairing hands-on learning activities with picture books, and there are some wonderful Thanksgiving stories that work beautifully with this pumpkin pie counting game!
Here are a few favorites.
How Many Seeds in a Pumpkin? by Margaret McNamara
This sweet picture book introduces counting, estimation, and mathematical thinking through a classroom pumpkin investigation.
How Many Seeds In A Pumpkin? is a wonderful choice for extending number recognition and counting practice after playing the pumpkin pie matching game.
Find How Many Seeds in a Pumpkin? on Amazon
The Great Thanksgiving Escape by Mark Fearing
A funny Thanksgiving story about two cousins determined to escape the kids’ table.
Pair The Great Thanksgiving Escape with our pumpkin pie number matching game for a fun Thanksgiving-themed storytime and math activity.
Find The Great Thanksgiving Escape on Amazon
Bear Says Thanks by Karma Wilson
This heartwarming story about friendship and gratitude is a lovely addition to any Thanksgiving classroom read-aloud.
After reading Bear Says Thanks, invite children to play the pumpkin pie number matching game before completing our thankful turkey printable.
Find Bear Says Thanks on Amazon
A Plump and Perky Turkey by Teresa Bateman
A clever turkey manages to outsmart the townspeople in this funny Thanksgiving story!
Pair A Plump and Perky Turkey with our pumpkin pie counting game and one of our colorful turkey crafts for a fun afternoon of Thanksgiving learning.
Find A Plump and Perky Turkey on Amazon
How to Catch a Turkey by Adam Wallace
This hilarious Thanksgiving story follows a turkey on the loose at school!
After reading How To Catch A Turkey, children can practice their counting skills with the pumpkin pie matching game before making a colorful turkey craft.
Find How to Catch a Turkey on Amazon
More Fall and Thanksgiving Activities for Kids
Looking for more screen-free activities to keep little learners busy this fall?
Be sure to check out these collections for even more inspiration:
- Thanksgiving Crafts and Activities for Kids – Easy Thanksgiving crafts, learning activities, games, and free printables.
- November Crafts and Activities – Seasonal art projects and learning ideas for the entire month.
- Turkey Crafts and Activities for Kids – A collection of adorable turkey crafts, printables, and hands-on activities.
- Pumpkin Crafts for Kids – Fun pumpkin art projects and activities for preschool and kindergarten.
- Fall Crafts for Kids – Creative autumn crafts and seasonal activities.
- Too Many Pumpkins Crafts and Activities – Fun crafts and learning activities inspired by a favorite fall picture book.
Final Thoughts on This Thanksgiving Pumpkin Pie Number Matching Game
I hope your little learners have as much fun with this Thanksgiving pumpkin pie number matching game as we do!
It’s such a simple way to make counting and number recognition a little more exciting during November.
Whether you’re using it in a preschool math center, adding it to your kindergarten morning tubs, or enjoying some screen-free learning at home, this printable is a fun way to help children build confidence with numbers 1–10.
And if your kids love pumpkin pie as much as mine do, don’t forget to check out our other pumpkin pie crafts and Thanksgiving activities for even more seasonal fun!
Happy Thanksgiving and happy learning! 🥧🧡
